Over 4,000 UK Subscribers
  SUBSCRIBE for FREE!  
E-mail
     
Essential Films
Mission Dec08
Big Lies
24HR
 
E-mail to a friend  
Print this page  

Text Size:   A   A

BBC Reporter: Genuine Eyewitness or Palestinian Propagandist?

Whose version of events does a BBC journalist stand by?

HonestReporting's international site has critiqued a BBC "From Our Own Correspondent" programme by Aleem Maqbool reporting from Ramallah, where he includes this dramatic story:

One weekday last year, at about three in the afternoon, Israeli armoured jeeps moved into the centre of Ramallah, pulling up outside the most popular hummus cafe.

In full view of passers-by, including children on their way back from school, the troops dragged a man in his early 20s out of the cafe. He was a wanted militant. They shot him - first in the legs, then stomach, then his head.

Within minutes, the "Palestinian reflex" had kicked in. Schoolboys piled into the area to throw stones at the soldiers until they left. As we arrived, the troops fired back with live bullets, injuring four people, before the jeeps sped out of the city.

In the next paragraph Maqbool implies that he was an eyewitness to this incident, which is portrayed as an IDF "execution":

Once the army had gone, I have to say, I was a little surprised to see grown Palestinian men standing by the side of the road, weeping and hugging, and teenagers who'd been throwing stones, breaking down.

Maqbool appears to be describing the death of Palestinian terrorist Omar Abdel-Halim. CAMERA, however, investigated media coverage of this incident and discovered countless contradictions between the accounts of so-called Palestinian "eyewitnesses", Palestinian NGOs and media outlets, which could not even agree on the correct name of the terrorist.

Read the whole story and find out more at HonestReporting's latest communique: BBC Reporter: Genuine Eyewitness or Palestinian Propagandist?

IS IT TIME TO GIVE UP ON THE BBC?

The BBC is a constant source of exasperation as the Zionist Federation's Gavin Gross describes in The Jerusalem Post. In his dealings with the BBC, a number of incidents leave us wondering whether the BBC's attitude towards Israel is borne of malice or simply ignorance and stupidity:

"In April I did appear in the BBC TV program Aliyah - The Journey Home? produced by its religion department and broadcast during Pessah as part of the BBC Charter's requirement for non-Christian programming. While I was told the program set out to examine the spiritual and religious motivations for British Jewish aliya, I was asked mainly political questions about the Palestinian right of return and Israel's treatment of its Arab citizens.

The producers used Antony Lerman, an anti-Zionist Jewish academic, as one of their on-air experts even though Lerman has called publicly for the repeal of Israel's Law of Return and for the evolution of a single Israel-Palestine state. When I queried the use of Lerman on such a program, given that his views on aliya and Israel represent a tiny fringe of Anglo-Jewish opinion, the executive producer told me that Lerman had the support of significant Jewish figures such as Haim Bresheeth, who the producer referred to as a reputable academic and noted author.

Bresheeth, an Israeli-born academic and activist within the UK's University and College Union (UCU), regularly calls for a full boycott of Israeli academic institutions and was quoted by The Jerusalem Post as telling a "Resisting Israeli Apartheid" conference at London University that: "The occupation started in 1948" and "There is no valid comparison between South Africa and Israel; Israel is much worse. South Africa exploited its native population while Israel expelled and committed genocide against its native population." Is it ignorance or malice that would lead a BBC producer to credit this man with being an important representative of the Jewish community?"

Read the full article here.

ISRAELI AMBASSADOR SPEAKS OUT

Writing in The Daily Telegraph, Israel's ambassador to the UK, Ron Prosor takes Britain to account for its anti-Israel sentiment, arguing that "coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is routinely tainted with bias and a surprising lack of context":

Fairness is all too frequently absent in a debate that has been hijacked by extremists.

Israel faces an intensified campaign of delegitimisation, demonisation and double standards. Britain has become a hotbed for radical anti-Israeli views and a haven for disingenuous calls for a "one-state solution", a euphemistic name for a movement advocating Israel's destruction.

Read the full article here.

WIN A FREE TRIP TO ISRAEL!

Sign up to enter the drawing, and if you're not already a subscriber, you'll begin receiving HonestReporting UK communiques, joining the effort to ensure Israel receives fair and accurate coverage in the British media.

Refer friends and for each friend who registers with HonestReporting UK, you will receive an extra chance to WIN!

Click here for the chance to win the Grand Prize of 2 airline tickets to Israel, a second prize of 5 iPod Touches + 10 other great prizes to be won!

THE BIG LIES

The al-Dura affair is one of a number of media manipulations and distortions covered in our exciting new interactive resource - The Big Lies.

You will be able to navigate through several case studies of untrue accusations that were reported as facts. Each study has an introduction, an explanation of the lie, the lie reported in the media, and the actual facts of the case.

If you haven't already done so, check out The Big Lies by clicking on the image below.

 
HonestReporting UK
Thank you for your involvement in responding
to media bias.

Go
Home   Media Critique Archive   Fair Use   Email Us   ©2008 HonestReporting HRUK